iPhoneography Apps – Tintype: Nice results, troubling interface

Last time I covered an app that emulated a particular type of photography: Polaroid, or instant, photography. This week I go back to the dawn of photography and the time when photo prints did not come on paper, but on metal: the tintype.

Polaroids were all about catching the moment; tintypes were the opposite. Painstakingly staged and allowing for no movement, tintypes have a static look that warrant the use of a permanent metal to print them.

The app Tintype is made by Hipstamatic, who have some experience with the look in their Tintype Hipstamatic Pak, which included the Tinto 1884 lens and D-Plate and C-Plate films. When separating the Tintype look into its own app, you’d expect that Hipstamatic would add value by giving you more control over the look of the resulting output. Unfortunately, that expectation is both true and not true.

Tintype_01

Just like Polamatic, the app is simple to use. It starts you with the camera, with controls to choose an image from your library or switch from the rear to the front camera. There’s a box in the center to show you what would be included in a square image.

Tintype_02

After capturing the image, you are taken to the Edit screen with the effect already applied. At the top are options to Delete or Save the capture. At the bottom are four buttons. From left to right, they are Style/Crop, Frame, Eye Intensity, and Depth of Field.

Tintype_03

Tapping the Style/Cop button brings up the options for Style and Crop. The three Styles are black and white, color and sepia. Black and white is the default.

Tintype_04

The Color Style is a muted color, as you would expect from an emulation of a process from before Technicolor.

Tintype_05

The Sepia has a bit too much color for my taste. I would take my sepia images into Snapseed or some other editing app to desaturate them further.

Tintype_06

Crop leaves you with two options: original and square. Tintype does not allow for zooming or dragging the crop box; a square crop is always taken out of the exact center of the image, whether the image is captured or comes from the Camera Roll. This is the first instance where the user is allowed some control, but not nearly enough.

Tintype_07

Under the Frame control are Plate Grain and the option to turn the Frame on and off. Plate Grain is a slider that controls the amount of grunge. Below I’ve shown Plate Grain at maximum.

Tintype_08

Next I show the Plate Grain at minimum. The Frame button just turns the frame on and off. There is no option to rotate the frame or grain to get different looks. The frame and grain are part of the Style; there is no way to use the frame for the Black and White Style with the Sepia tint.

Tintype_09

The next option is Eye Intensity. If you look at old tintypes, they had a way of emphasizing the eyes of a portrait subject by sharpening and lightening them. Because our current image is a still-life and not a portrait, the Eye icon has a slash through it. There are no eyes to intensify. I will therefore go into my library to get a portrait.

As you can see below, Tintype does not give you a list of albums. Instead they show a “Moments”-style representation of your Camera Roll and Photo Stream, with no option to choose from other albums you may have.

Tintype_10

By the way, the Library view is where Settings are found (the Gear icon at the upper right). The only Setting is the Save Photos option. Right now I have that set as Always Ask. The different Save options will be discussed in a moment.

Tintype_11

Below I’ve loaded a selfie, and selected the Eye Intensity option. It’s a slider which defaults to the middle position. It is only available if the app can determine that the subject is a portrait with visible eyes.

Tintype_12

The slider controls sharpness and lightness together. Below I like the sharpness when the Intensity slider is at the max, but not the lightness.

Tintype_13

The eye recognition is hit or miss. The image below has two sets of eyes, but Tintype was unable to recognize them. The same thing happens when there is only a single eye, such as when a selfie cuts off one side of your face. (I’d love to be able to have a really intense single-eye shot.) The lack of user control is also a problem here. The app should allow for an “intensity area” or areas.

Tintype_14

The last control is Depth of Field, or the amount of blurring toward the edges of the image. Below you can see that Tintype allows for a large amount of blurring.

Tintype_15

That was too much; my jawline nearly disappears. Below I’ve dialed it back so there’s even less blurring than the default.

Tintype_16

Up at the top right of the edit screen is the Save button. When the Settings (shown above) are set to Always Ask, tapping Save will ask you if you want to save a Version or a Copy. Saving a Version means that you will be able to Revert that image to the original while within the Camera Roll, outside of Tintype. I, for safety’s sake, prefer to always Save a Copy. I changed the Settings after capturing the screenshots to reflect that I always want to save a copy.

Tintype_17

Here’s my Tintype selfie.

Tintype_18

Once you’ve saved your image, you are taken to a screen where you can Share your image. If you don’t wish to Share, tap Done at the upper right.

Tintype_19

Tapping the More button brings up the standard iOS dialog.

Tintype_20

Once again, I want to emphasize that the eye recognition is chancy. Whereas it wasn’t able to recognize the two pairs of eyes in the example I showed above, it had no problem with the doll below.

Tintype_21

I’m torn on Tintype. I like the results a lot, but the lack of control – only slightly more control than is offered with the Tintype Pak in Hipstamatic – means that I can’t really justify recommending it. I hope that the folks at Hipstamatic improve the user interface, rather than abandoning the app altogether.

Let’s finish with a few examples. First, a bottle of red.

Tintype_22

Next, a shady post office.

Tintype_23

Finally, an image from Hollywood Studios that’s really suited to a tintype effect.

Tintype_24

Until next time, enjoy!

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: